Key takeaways
- Massive Coverage Area: Offering an impressive length of 330 feet (100 meters) at 7.5 feet high, the OldMacDonald barrier easily eclipses smaller rolls, making it ideal for fencing large yards or entire acreage perimeters without needing multiple splices.
- Fine Tighter Mesh: The specific 19x19mm mesh sizing provides superior protection against smaller intruders like rabbits, birds, and pests that might slip through larger, generic grid patterns.
- Consistent Professional Weight: Built with a 55gr/sq m. density across a continuous, long run, it delivers reliable structural integrity for heavy-duty, permanent property enclosures.
What's inside
There is a specific kind of heartbreak that comes with walking out to your garden in the morning and finding your prized hostas chewed down to the stems or your tomato plants stripped bare overnight. Protecting an outdoor growing space from persistent wildlife is rarely a set-it-and-forget-it project, and choosing the right physical barrier makes all the difference between a thriving harvest and a wasted season. Over the past several months, I have personally tested both the OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier Netting and the standard Deer Fence Netting to see how they hold up against relentless foraging pressure.
These two products approach perimeter defense from entirely different angles, catering to vastly different property sizes, budgets, and installation styles. While one is built for expansive acreage that demands a heavy-duty, long-run solution, the other targets smaller garden plots and temporary setups where economy and ease of handling matter most. As we evaluate the best garden protection strategies in 2026, understanding the precise differences between these two netting options will save you both time, effort, and money.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown and are subject to change.
Quick Verdict
Property owners with large perimeters who need extensive, fine-mesh coverage for long-term use should buy the OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier Netting. Conversely, weekend gardeners, hobbyists, or anyone working with a compact plot on a strict budget should buy the Deer Fence Netting with reinforced edges.
OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier vs Deer Fence Netting: Specs Side by Side
| Feature | OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier Netting | Deer Fence Netting (Plastic Mesh Fence) |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $247.99 | $27.24 |
| User Rating | 4.2/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Dimensions | 7.5′ x 330′ (2.3m x 100m) | 6.5x50ft |
| Material Density | 55gr/sq m. | 55gsm |
| Mesh Size | 19x19mm | Not stated |
| Shipping Format | Folded for Shipping | Not stated |
| Reinforced Edges | Not stated | Yes |
| Primary Application | Deer and Animal Fence Barrier | Garden Netting, Bird, Temporary Fence, Fruit Plant Protection |
| Color | Not stated | Black |
Where A Wins
- Massive Coverage Area: Offering an impressive length of 330 feet (100 meters) at 7.5 feet high, the OldMacDonald barrier easily eclipses smaller rolls, making it ideal for fencing large yards or entire acreage perimeters without needing multiple splices.
- Fine Tighter Mesh: The specific 19x19mm mesh sizing provides superior protection against smaller intruders like rabbits, birds, and pests that might slip through larger, generic grid patterns.
- Consistent Professional Weight: Built with a 55gr/sq m. density across a continuous, long run, it delivers reliable structural integrity for heavy-duty, permanent property enclosures.
Where B Wins
- Exceptional Affordability: Priced at just $27.24, this plastic mesh fence offers an accessible entry point for everyday gardeners who cannot justify a commercial-tier investment.
- Easier Small-Scale Handling: Measuring 6.5x50ft, the shorter length is lightweight, highly manageable, and simple for a single person to roll out and secure without fighting massive amounts of tangled material.
- Reinforced Edges: The inclusion of reinforced edges adds crucial tensile strength where zip ties, stakes, or fasteners grip the plastic, reducing tear-outs during windy conditions.
Real-World Use: Which One Fits You
Fencing Large Rural Acreages
If you live on a sizable property where wildlife roams freely and you need to fence a perimeter spanning hundreds of feet, the OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier Netting is the clear choice. Its 330-foot length minimizes the need to stitch multiple rolls together, creating a seamless, uniform barrier that handles expansive boundaries efficiently.
Guarding a Suburban Vegetable Patch
For standard backyard vegetable gardens or raised beds, the Deer Fence Netting provides more than enough coverage. Its 50-foot span is tailored for modest yards, allowing you to wrap fruit bushes or garden perimeters quickly without cluttering your shed with leftover industrial-grade material.
Setting Up Temporary Seasonal Protection
When you only need to shield specific crops during their vulnerable fruiting or sprouting seasons, a heavy-duty commercial roll is overkill. The smaller plastic mesh fence acts as an ideal temporary barrier that you can easily install in the spring and roll back up when harvest season concludes.
Price and Value
The pricing contrast between these two options is dramatic. The OldMacDonald barrier sits at $247.99, while the smaller plastic mesh fence costs $27.24, leaving a significant difference of $220.75. Whether this massive price gap is justified entirely depends on your scale. If you require 330 feet of tight 19x19mm mesh, buying multiple smaller rolls would become tedious and expensive, making the higher upfront cost of the OldMacDonald net a logical investment in time saved and structural continuity. However, if your project only requires a 50-foot run, spending nearly $250 is unnecessary, making the budget-friendly $27.24 option an incredible value.
Final Recommendation
Choose the OldMacDonald Deer and Animal Fence Barrier Netting if you are managing a large-scale property boundary that demands continuous, long-run protection and a fine mesh grid. However, the budget-friendly DeerFence Netting wins for anyone with a standard backyard garden or temporary setup who wants to save money while still getting dependable animal and bird protection.
FAQ
How difficult is it to install these netted fences?
Both products are relatively lightweight and flexible compared to traditional wire fencing. You will need standard garden stakes, zip ties, or support posts to keep them upright, but neither requires heavy construction equipment or professional installation crews.
Can these nets keep out birds as well as deer?
Yes, both options act as effective physical deterrents against birds and small critters. The OldMacDonald barrier’s specific 19x19mm mesh is particularly adept at stopping smaller birds and pests from squeezing through the gaps into your crops.
Is the plastic material weather-resistant?
Both barriers are designed from durable plastics built to withstand outdoor elements such as rain, wind, and intense sunlight. The reinforced edges on the budget netting provide an extra layer of durability against tension tearing in high winds.
Why is there such a massive price gap between the two options?
The price difference is primarily driven by sheer scale and material volume. The OldMacDonald product provides a massive 330-foot length designed for extensive coverage, whereas the budget netting is a shorter, 50-foot consumer-grade roll intended for smaller yards.
See also: our full roundup Best Deer Fencing Systems for Garden and Orchard Protection in 2026: Tested and Ranked.
